Does A mother has a right to humiliate her married son on the basis of her assumption that he is commiting haram, or does she has the right to investigate or expose his private sins that he is concealing between himself and Allah.
A mother has no right to humiliate her son on the basis of her assumption if he is innocent, nor does she has the right to investigate or expose his private sins that he is concealing between himself and Allah in a manner that destroys his marriage, reputation and honor.A person may be weak, struggling with sin, sincerely repenting, and repeatedly turning back to Allah. Allah may forgive him, or Allah may expose him in this world or the Hereafter—that authority of forgiving or exposing belongs solely to Allah, not to His creation.
Allah says:
And do not spy, nor backbite one another.”(Qur’an 49:12)
This verse establishes a clear prohibition against tajassus (spying) and fault-finding, even when suspicion exists.
The responsibility of a parent—or any believer—is only sincere advice (naṣīḥah), not investigation, exposure, or punishment. Allah says:
“So remind, for you are only a reminder.You are not a controller over them.”(Qur’an 88:21–22)
And Allah says:
“Your duty is only to convey; the reckoning is upon Us.”(Qur’an 13:40)
These verses clearly define the boundary: humans advise; Allah judges and executes.
If a person is an open sinner or clearly engaging in actions that cause direct and proven harm to others, such as he being a child abuser, rapist or caught repeatedly with other woman with no regret or any will to repent to Allah.Injustice or abuse of his wife, and this harm is established without spying, suspicion, or repeated investigation, then steps may be taken to remove the harm, including separation. This is based on preventing oppression—not on searching for hidden sins.
However, investigating a married son’s private belongings is extremely dangerous and often leads to injustice. What if a mother finds a condom that he lawfully uses with his wife? What if she finds private or intimate images belonging to him or his wife? What if she finds an item whose purpose she does not understand, though it is not sinful in the sight of Allah? Such actions can result in falsely accusing an innocent person or exposing someone who is striving to conceal his sins—both of which are prohibited.
The Messenger of Allah ﷺ warned that whoever searches for people’s hidden faults, Allah will expose his own faults, even within his home (reported in Sahih Muslim).
The principle established by the Qur’an and Sunnah is clear:concealed sins remain concealed, advice is given with wisdom, and judgment, exposure, and execution belong to Allah alone—unless a clear, proven harm to others necessitates lawful intervention.
Comments
Post a Comment